2003 | Kerrang! Awards | Best International Newcomer | Evanescence | Won |
MTV Europe Music Awards | Best Song | "Bring Me to Life" | Nominated |
Best Group | Evanescence | Nominated |
Best New Act | Evanescence | Nominated |
2003 | Los Premios MTV Latinoamérica | Best Rock Artist — International | Evanescence | Nominated |
2004 | World Music Awards | Best Rock Artist | Evanescence | Won |
Grammy Award | Best New Artist[24] | Evanescence | Won |
Album of the Year[24] | Fallen | Nominated |
Best Rock Album[24] | Nominated |
Best Hard Rock Performance[24] | "Bring Me to Life" | Won |
Best Rock Song[24] | Nominated |
2004 | Los Premios MTV Latinoamérica | Best Rock Artist — International | Evanescence | Nominated |
2005 | Grammy Award | Best Pop Performance by a Duo or Group with Vocals[99] | "My Immortal" | Nominated |
2006 | MTV Europe Music Awards | Best Rock | Evanescence | Nominated |
2007 | Kerrang! Awards | Sexiest Female | Amy Lee | Won |
MTV Australia Awards | Album of the Year | The Open Door | Won |
Los Premios MTV Latinoamérica | Best Rock Artist — International | Evanescence | Won |
MTV Europe Music Awards | Rock Out | Evanescence | Nominated |
2008 | Grammy Award | Best Hard Rock Performance[100] | "Sweet Sacrifice" | Nominated |
2008 | National Music Publishers Association | Songwriter Icon Award | Amy Lee | Won |
2011 | Loudwire Music Awards | Rock Song of the Year[101] | "What You Want" | Won |
Comeback of the Year[101] | Evanescence | Won |
Artist of the Year[102] | Evanescence | Nominated |
Rock Album of the Year[102] | Evanescence | Nominated |
Rock Goddess of the Year[103] | Amy Lee | Nominated |
2012 | Revolver Golden Gods Award | Best Vocalist[104] | Amy Lee | Won |
Album of the Year[104] | Evanescence | Nominated |
Comeback of the Year[104] | Evanescence | Nominated |
Most Dedicated Fans[104] | Evanescence | Nominated |
Kerrang! Awards | Best International Band | Evanescence | Nominated |
Hottest Female | Amy Lee | Nominated |
MTV Europe Music Awards | Best World Stage Performance | Evanescence | Nominated |